A Tennessee Plan for Puerto Rico?

32 territories became states of the U.S. in the first two centuries of our history. For those territories that were organized under the Northwest Ordinance, statehood was the future planned for them by the federal government from the beginning. The unincorporated territory doctrine means that Congress has not been required to adopt any real plan for the future status of Puerto Rico.

That means a Tennessee Plan strategy for Puerto Rico might be different from the Tennessee Plan for territories organized under the Northwest Ordinance. To begin with, a Tennessee Plan for Puerto Rico would mean that Puerto Rico would no longer be an unincorporated territory waiting patiently for Congress to decide it fate. A Tennessee Plan for Puerto Rico might even require a proclamation that U.S. citizens in the territory no longer consent to unincorporated territory status so it is no longer legitimate on a particular date, just as Tennessee declared that their incorporated territory status ended on a date they chose.

For other Tennessee Plan territories, statehood was already established as the future political status of the territory, by Congress. Puerto Rico would in essence be declaring a future political status policy when Congress has not done so. This would also mean that Puerto Rico was not only setting aside unincorporated territory status, but bypassing incorporation and going straight from unincorporated territory status to statehood. No other unincorporated territory has done this, so Puerto Rico would be making history.

We might say that every territory made history when it became a state. If they used the Tennessee Plan, they just became states sooner than Congress chose. In the case of Puerto Rico, Congress has done nothing to make clear the future political status of the Island. The Tennessee Plan would force Congress not just to say that the time is right for statehood, but also that statehood is right for Puerto Rico. While each territory has a unique history, when all is said and done the transcendental power and transformational effect of democracy in action is what the Tennessee Plan has always been all about.

Obviously that requires a democratic mandate for statehood for Puerto Rico. However, given the large Puerto Rican population in the other states, the expanding political power of Hispanic voters, and the perversity of discrimination against 4 million U.S. citizens within the American political culture, Puerto Rico may be able to adapt the Tennessee plan to its unique position and make it work.

Or, it could fail in the short term but eventually lead to success, like it did for New Mexico.

Arguably, unincorporated territory status for Puerto Rico is a colonial condition, where incorporated territory status was part of an anti-colonial tradition for earlier American territories to become states. Puerto Rico, since Congress has not said it will certainly become a state in the future, can’t look with confidence toward a future of equal rights. Puerto Rico’s continued economic problems show the ongoing effects of this political limbo, and the numbers of Puerto Ricans moving to the mainland show the loss of hope that results.

For that very reason, the Tennessee Plan may be the best path for Puerto Rico. However, that path will lead to statehood only if Puerto Rico’s Tennessee Plan is well planned and carried out.

The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1982 that unincorporated territory status in Puerto Rico has evolved into a status “like a state”. Yet 4 million residents of the territory cannot vote for their president. The truth is Puerto Rico is a de facto state in most respects, but U.S. citizenship rights there are restricted.

That is what caused the U.S. citizens of Tennessee to step up and proclaim equality and full citizenship rights. If the people of Puerto Rico want equal rights and duties of national citizenship in the United States, they should do the same.

This post was originally written in English and may be being auto-translated by Google.

9 Comments

Lynn Jensen

I read and read this article and still can’t understand the gibberish. All I got was that Puerto Rico should just pick a date and declare that on that date they will become our 51st state!

Reply
Johnny Rebel

Of course not. Almost no puerto ricans who live in the actual 50 states wants statehood. Look at how many millions come out the the Puerto Rican Day parade or root against the USA and for Puerto Rico in the olympics. They either want to keep it as is or be an independent nation. These statehooders are looking for a handout…something else free. They are non productive welfare taking BUMS. It’s their fault the island is in so much debt. I say we cut em loose, they do nothing for America except beg, borrow and steal.

Reply
Kethy

The ones looking for handouts are DEMOCRATS. You would like for PR to be the same welfare state you have in the mainland. Rossello never asked for a bailout of any sort. Only the Democrats keep saying they want the island to be bailed out. The Democrats are running scared because P.R. is about to become a state of the Union. You live in the U.S. so you are FOR statehood already. If you were not born in Puerto Rico (like GUTIERREZ), you have nothing to say. This is why you troll these boards. You are livid that no one cares about what you are saying. No one cares because you don’t have any right to comment.

Reply
La verdad

NO! A Sovereign and Independent Puerto Rico is and always will be the ONLY HEALTHY WAY for Puerto Rico! Be who you are, a Puerto Rican!

Check out this link and learn about the real History of PR.

Reply
Ana Rivera

Yes I beleive that Puerto Rico citizens want statehood. The Tenessee plan os the Way to GO!

Reply
bootcamp808

The referendum held in Puerto Rico on June 11, 2017 only garnered a dismal 24 percent of all registered island voters. Of those voters, most are allies of Governor Rosello who advocate statehood. That is why the votes for statehood registered 95 percent. Those who abstained from the voting, are probably folks who do favor a political option that is other than statehood. What needs to happen is another refenedum should be held and a true look into how most of the islanders feel about the status of the island really is. The real truth is that statehood for Puerto Rico might not be what the Puerto Rican people really want.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.