Sen. Schumer Forgets How Democracy Works

Senator Schumer said, before the 2020 plebiscite, that he would “love to” make Puerto Rico a state, “especially if they vote for it.”

Puerto Rico voted for statehood.

Certified Results of the 2020 Puerto Rico Plebiscite

Schumer has now backpedaled on taking action, it seems. He told El Nuevo Dia, a Puerto Rico news source, that he is “waiting for a consensus to develop”.

The Chairman of the Democratic Party of Puerto Rico, Charles Rodriguez, responded, “You can’t ask the people of Puerto Rico to vote and then ignore what they democratically decide with their ballots”.

That’s not how democracy works

In a hearing on Puerto Rico’s status, the U.S. Senate brought together the leaders of Puerto Rico’s political parties in an effort to create consensus on political status. The effort failed, and the exasperated senators asked the Puerto Rican leaders what they could do without full agreement on a status preference.

Now Governor, then Resident Commissioner, Pedro Pierluisi said, “That’s not how democracy works.” He spoke the truth. Democracy does not require consensus.

Schumer did not say that we should wait for the American people to develop consensus around a presidential candidate before inaugurating Joe Biden. He didn’t ask for consensus when he won his senate seat for the first time with 51% in the primary and 54% in the general election.

This is because Schumer understands that elections in the United States are based on the majority of votes, not on attempts to get everyone to agree.

A legitimate ballot is a legitimate act of self determination.

Will he keep his word?

“I trust that when Senator Schumer considers the issue further, he will keep his word to Puerto Ricans,” Charlie Rodriguez continued.  “He should know that a poll in his own State – which has 1.1 million Puerto Ricans – found that up to 78% of Puerto Ricans in New York not only supported statehood but supported a ‘Statehood: Yes or No’ vote. That was the question Puerto Rico voted on November 3rd and on which an indisputable majority voted for statehood.”

One thing that is clear is that Puerto Rico does not benefit from being an unincorporated U.S. territory. Some individuals may benefit, but Puerto Rico would be better off as a state. Tell Senator Schumer so.

@SenSchumer Puerto Rico voted for statehood and needs the equality statehood will bring. Please keep your promise to support equality for Puerto Rico. Consensus is not a requirement; respecting the vote is. Click To Tweet

One Comment

AA AA

Highly predictable. Painful to watch. The result of polarized lobbying in Congress by multiple political and financial groups. One thing is clear: P Rico cannot continue on it’s current path. It is not fair to the USA Citizens living in the island, who hope for a better future. It is not fair to keep the Island of PR hostage for political and financial exploitation by the public and private sectors.

Ironically, illegal immigrants seem to have a protective voice in the USA congress. Yet, the US citizens of PR and the PR veterans who reside there- do not. Mr. Schumer forgets that the economic debacle of PR was caused- not only -by the incompetence and negligence of the island political leaders and multiple administrations -but also, by the unfair unincorporated territorial laws through which they had and still have, to operate.

It is pass time for the USA Congress to act constitutionally towards PR. Statehood won fair and square in a democratic election. The details of the transition can be worked out. To delay the will of the people, viciously and for political reasons its unconstitutional and simply shameful.

Most citizens quote how the Declaration of Independence starts… “When in the course of human events…”
Few emphasize how it ends: “ That these United Colonies are, and of right ought to be, FREE AND INDEPENDENT STATES, ………. and for the support of this declaration, with a firm Reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes and our SACRED HONOR.”

Mr. Schumer and ALL congress members must HONOR our nation’s history, Our Declaration of Independence and our US Constitution.

Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.