José Fernando Pérez Martínez shares frustration with the inequitable access to services like education and healthcare in Puerto Rico. This inequity, he says, causes Puerto Ricans to leave their families and move to the states. Puerto Rico’s health care system is part of the problem.
One of the top reasons people leave the Island is for healthcare. The health care system in Puerto Rico is less robust than that in the states. Access to healthcare is a problem and quality of care can also be an issue. Why should Puerto Rico’s health care system be as limited and fragile as it is, when Puerto Rico is a center for biotechnology, the production of medications and medical devices, and medical research?
Funding
Nearly half of Puerto Rico residents are eligible from Medicaid, and another quarter are on Medicare. The remainder use health insurance through employers. The proportions in the states are the opposite — about 35% use federal funding and two-thirds have health insurance, usually through employers. This means that federal funding for healthcare is especially important in Puerto Rico.
Yet federal healthcare funding in Puerto Rico is far more limited than in the states. State governments are reimbursed by the federal government according to what they spend, but Puerto Rico receives a block grant — a set amount of money, much lower than if they were a state — and must figure out how to spread it across the greater need on the Island.
Administrative issues
In a state, a recipient of Medicare Part A automatically is also signed up for Part B, which covers hospital stays. This is not true in Puerto Rico. Part D, for prescription drugs, is not available at all in Puerto Rico. Most Medicare recipient instead use Medicare Advantage plans, which often cost more. Far fewer Medicare patients in states use these add-on plans.
For both Medicare and Medicaid, the reimbursement rates for medical professionals are lower than in the states. Put simply, this means that doctors and hospitals get paid less. They have to reduce costs for care, which often means just reducing care.
Additionally, some services are not covered in Puerto Rico. For example, long-term care for the elderly is not available.
And since funding is inevitably inadequate, Puerto Rico must go back to Congress to ask for more when the territory government runs out. This means that actual funding is unpredictable, so planning and price negotiations are inefficient.
Staffing
People in Puerto Rico have been leaving the Island for decades. At this point, twice as many Puerto Ricans live in a state as on the Island. Among people leaving the Island for the benefits of statehood are many healthcare professionals. There are too few doctors, too few specialists, and too few support staff to serve the people living on the Island.
This is certainly related to funding and administration issues. But at the basic level, it’s clear that living in a state is better than living in a territory. Living in the state of Puerto Rico would be better than living in the territory of Puerto Rico.
Health concerns
Puerto Rico has higher rates of most chronic diseases than states. There are many factors involved in this situation, including these facts:
- The population of the Island is older on average than people living in the states.
- 85% of Puerto Rico’s food is imported, so people are eating less fresh, local food.
- The poverty rate is higher in Puerto Rico, leading to greater stress and potentially fewer opportunities for healthy lifestyle choices.
Once again, this is a situation in which the need is greater — but Puerto Rico’s health care system’s resources are more limited.
What causes the inequity?
Territory status leads inevitably to poverty, and poverty increases reliance on government funding for healthcare. Congress provides less for Puerto Rico not because of something special about Puerto Rico, but because it is legal to do so.
Congress cannot give less funding to Mississippi because they are a poor state, or to states like Virginia that already get higher federal investment than they pay into the system. States have equal rights and must be treated equally under the law. When Congress needs to save money, cutting funds for Alaska or Hawaii is not an option.
They are allowed to treat territories differently from states, and to treat one territory differently from another. When they need to save money, they can reduce funding for Puerto Rico. It’s not personal. It’s territory status. And remember, “commonwealth” status is identical to territory status.
Statehood is the solution. No collection of piecemeal, temporary benefits will fix the problem. Statehood provides equal rights, and that will fix the problem. Tell your representative to get on the right side of history and admit Puerto Rico now.
No responses yet